Paola Santiago
Good
Night, and Good Luck depicts
the rise to ultimate broadcasting fame and pride through Edward R. Murrow’s
efforts to uncover the realities surrounding Senator Joseph McCarthy – a highly
volatile political figure who helped spread the fear of communists during the
Red Scare in the 1950s.
In the first part of this film,
we see the birth of basic ethical issues that the Columbia Broadcasting System,
or CBS, must grapple with during the course of the events involving Murrow’s
newscasts and McCarthy’s fear mongering. Some of these issues include the
stakeholders, conflicts of interest and objectivity.
Photo Credit: Neural Pop
Stakeholders
We can easily tell that CBS is
the biggest stakeholder. As they are the employer of Murrow and they supply his
team, anything he does reflects on them. Of course, Murrow is also a
stakeholder. He could lose his job, reputation and respect from the public. We
can visibly see Murrow struggle with this reality at the close of each of his casts.
The public is also as stakeholder in this scenario as Murrow’s words incited a social upheaval since surely some of his listeners might have also been supporters of McCarthy. Finally, and most importantly, the senator himself was the most important stakeholder as Murrow was driving a blow of doubt through the scares that McCarthy promoted.
The public is also as stakeholder in this scenario as Murrow’s words incited a social upheaval since surely some of his listeners might have also been supporters of McCarthy. Finally, and most importantly, the senator himself was the most important stakeholder as Murrow was driving a blow of doubt through the scares that McCarthy promoted.
Conflicts of Interest
Though not directly related to
the issues concerning McCarthy, is the relationship between Shirley and Joe Wershba.
They are compelled to keep their relationship a secret because of workplace
rules forbidding romantic relationships between coworkers, a rule that is still
held in most workplaces today. These two manage to aid efforts against McCarthy
despite having to keep their marriage a secret to their employer and their
team. This demonstrates perhaps one of the greatest acts of journalism – the ability
to put aside personal interest for the sake of truth and obligation to the
public and their goals as journalists.
Objectivity
Keeping in mind the political and
social issues of the time, it was difficult for Murrow and his team to keep an
objective eye throughout the process of the McCarthy newscasts. At the start of
Murrow’s first newscast, he explains that in no way does the newscast reflect the
views of CBS nor are the intentions of the newscast to accuse the senator –
that they were merely a demonstration of investigative journalism and
truth telling. Murrow even offers McCarthy a chance to speak for himself during
the newscasts, furthering his knowledge of who his obligations were to and who
he knew the stakeholders were.
This film is an outstanding
example of the ethical issues and dilemmas journalists faced back then and will
continue to face for as long as our goal is one of truth. The first half of the
film shows only the tip of an ethical iceberg that the journalism world
scratches away at every day.
No comments:
Post a Comment